“It’s Up to You, Petula” – Edison Lighthouse’s Melodic Tribute to Love and Choice
Released in 1970, “It’s Up to You, Petula” by Edison Lighthouse is a heartfelt pop song that beautifully captures the essence of youthful romance and the bittersweet nature of love. Following the massive success of their hit “Love Grows (Where My Rosemary Goes),” Edison Lighthouse continued to impress listeners with this follow-up single, showcasing their knack for catchy melodies and emotive lyrics. This track reached the Top 20 in the UK and further solidified the band’s place in the pop music landscape of the early 1970s.
Lyrically, “It’s Up to You, Petula” speaks to the theme of choice in a romantic relationship, as the narrator expresses a deep yearning for the affection of Petula, while also recognizing the power of her decision. The lyrics reflect a delicate balance between hope and uncertainty, with lines like, “It’s up to you, Petula, to make up your mind,” capturing the essence of waiting and longing for someone to reciprocate feelings. This sentiment resonates universally, tapping into the emotional complexities that often accompany love. The use of a personal name in the title adds an intimate touch, inviting listeners to connect with the narrator’s plight on a more personal level.
Musically, “It’s Up to You, Petula” features the signature sound of early ’70s pop, characterized by jangly guitars, rich harmonies, and a melodic structure that is both infectious and memorable. The instrumentation is bright and uplifting, with a catchy chorus that invites sing-alongs. The arrangement includes lush backing vocals and a steady rhythm that perfectly complements the narrative of longing. The song’s upbeat tempo contrasts with its introspective lyrics, creating an engaging dynamic that keeps listeners invested in the story being told.
The charm of Edison Lighthouse shines through in this track, combining a catchy pop sensibility with thoughtful lyricism. “It’s Up to You, Petula” stands out as a testament to the band’s ability to create music that resonates with both the heart and the ears. Although not as commercially successful as their previous hit, the song has endured as a beloved classic, appreciated by fans of the era and those discovering it anew. Its themes of love, choice, and longing continue to speak to listeners, making it a timeless piece that captures the essence of romantic hope in a beautifully melodic package. Through its harmonious blend of thoughtful lyrics and catchy instrumentation, “It’s Up to You, Petula” remains a cherished gem in the landscape of pop music from the early 1970s.
Great Songs