The Temptations – Girl (Why You Wanna Make Me Blue): A Prelude to Motown’s Evolution
Released in 1964, “Girl (Why You Wanna Make Me Blue)” stands as a pivotal track in the early journey of The Temptations, both musically and historically. Written by Edward Holland Jr. and Norman Whitfield, the song marked the beginning of Whitfield’s tenure as a producer for the group—a role that would eventually redefine the sound and success of The Temptations and Motown itself.
The song radiates the energy and optimism of Motown’s golden era, driven by Eddie Kendricks’ unmistakable falsetto. Kendricks, whose voice conveys equal parts vulnerability and passion, brings a heartfelt urgency to the lyrics. This would be his third consecutive lead vocal for the group, perfectly capturing the torment of unrequited love and the confusion of emotional rejection. His delivery, infused with a soulful sincerity, makes every note feel personal and relatable.
Musically, the track showcases Motown’s signature polished production. With an up-tempo groove, punchy horns, and a driving rhythm section, it mirrors the vibrancy and innovation of the era. The Funk Brothers’ instrumental prowess is evident in every note, their dynamic playing providing a propulsive foundation that elevates the song’s emotional weight.
“Girl (Why You Wanna Make Me Blue)” also serves as a glimpse into Norman Whitfield’s early production style. While his later work with The Temptations would delve into socially conscious themes and psychedelic soul, this song captures a more straightforward yet impeccably crafted approach. The infectious melody and intricate harmonies hint at the musical sophistication Whitfield would later bring to classics like “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg” and “Papa Was a Rollin’ Stone.”
Though the song peaked at a modest No. 26 on the Billboard Hot 100, it remains a significant piece in The Temptations’ extensive catalog. It marked the end of an era for Kendricks as the primary lead singer on A-sides, paving the way for David Ruffin’s emergence as the group’s dominant voice. Moreover, it signified Whitfield’s rising prominence within the Motown ecosystem, setting the stage for his groundbreaking collaborations with the group in subsequent years.
Over time, “Girl (Why You Wanna Make Me Blue)” has gained recognition not only for its craftsmanship but also for its role in shaping the trajectory of The Temptations and Motown Records. It encapsulates the heartache and youthful yearning that defined much of early 1960s soul, while hinting at the evolution and experimentation that would come to define the latter half of the decade. A stepping stone in the group’s journey, the song remains a testament to their talent and the enduring magic of Motown.